Patent/copyright infringement
lawsuits/licensing awards

Center for Global Innovation/Patent Metrics
February 2013

Note: the table has not been updated in about ten years. It is on our list of things to do.

What follows is a table listing the monetary awards that companies have received because they were either victorious in an IP infringement lawsuit, or they negotiated deal in the absense/presence of a infringement lawsuit, or related technology litigation such as antitrust. The following monetary awards are culled from media reports of such victories/successes, and may have been reversed/reduced in later appeals, though we are constantly updating our records to include more awards, and more history on each award.

(Note: 'P.' prefix stands for patents, 'C.' prefix stands for copyrights). Dollar amounts in parentheses indicate the original judgment was reversed.

Patent infringement lawsuits/licensing awards
Amount Year Parties Legal Action Technology Reference
$3,250,000,000 2013 Elan Pharmaceuticals <- Biogen Idec P.Buyout Pharmaceutical Forbes, Feb 2013
$2,500,000,000 2002 Major League Baseball <-- Fox Television C.License Sports BCB1000
$1,725,000,000 1996 NCAA Basketball <-- CBS C.License Sports BCB0698
$1,350,000,000 2005 Karlin Technology <-- Medtronics P.Settlement Medical NYT0504
$1,000,000,000 2000 SnapTrack <-- Qualcomm Buyout Electronics SJMN0100
$873,000,000 1991 Polaroid <-- Eastman Kodak P.Lawsuit Chemical USPQ1617
$820,000,000 2001 Hallmark Entertainment <-- Crown Media C.Buyout Miniseries DV0401
$761,000,000 [RealNetworks +34%] 2005 RealNetworks <-- Microsoft Antitrust Online Entertainment WSJ0511
$750,000,000 2005 Medinol <-- Boston Scientific Contracts/Designs Medical NYT0509
$700,000,000 1997 Digital <-- Intel P.Lawsuit Computer IW1197
($625,000,000) 2011 Mirror Worlds <- Apple P.Lawsuit Software HuffPost, Apr 2011
($593,000,000) 2011 Bruce Saffran <- Johnson & Johnson P.Lawsuit Medical Wall Street Journal, Apr 2013
$505,000,000 2002 Igen International <-- Roche Holding P.Lawsuit Drugs WSJ0102
$500,000,000+ 1990 Texas Instruments <-- Toshiba P.Settlement Electronics EET1290
$500,000,000 2002 Paramount Pictures <-- KirchMedia C.License Movies LAT1202
$500,000,000 2002 City of Hope Nat Med Cent <-- Genentech P.Lawsuit Drugs SFC0602a
$500,000,000 1998 College Football <-- ABC C.License Sports BCB0698
$475,000,000 2002 SpinBrush Inc. <-- Procter & Gamble P.Buyout Mechanical BW0802
$475,000,000 2002 Major League Baseball <-- NBC C.License Sports BCB1000
$470,000,000 2002 Lucas Licensing <-- Hasbro C.License Toys SJMN0203
$465,000,000 [Lexar +104%] 2005 Lexar <-- Toshiba Trade Secret Electronics SFC0503
$453,000,000 2002 InterTrust <-- Sony, Philips P.Buyout Software WSJ1102c
$424,000,000+ 2002 Medical Instrument. <-- Elekta P.Lawsuit Medical INT006
$420,000,000 2001 Litton Industries <-- Honeywell P.Settlement Electronics AWST0993
$400,000,000 2001 Pitney Bowes <-- HP P.Settlement Software WSJ0601
$380,000,000 2002 Immunex <-- Schering AG P.Buyout Drugs WSJ0502a
$375,000,000 1998 Int. Olym. Comm. <-- CBS C.License Sports BCB0194
$368,000,000 2013 VirnetX <-- Apple P.Lawsuit Software Feb 2013 PR
$350,000,000 1993 NBA <-- Turner Broadcasting C.License Sports BCB0993
$340,000,000 2001 Winnie-The-Pooh estate <-- Walt Disney C.Buyout Story characters WSJ0301
$330,000,000+ 2003 Idenix Pharmaceuticals <-- Novartis P.License Drugs WSJ0303
$325,000,000 2005 EMC <-- Hewlett Packard P.Settlement Computers WSJ0505
$325,000,000 2002 Amylin Pharmaceuticals <-- Eli Lilly P.License Drugs NYT0902
($324,000,000) 2000 Cordis/Johnson & Johnson <-- Boston Scientific P.Lawsuit Medical WSJ12001
$301,000,000 1993 Motown <-- Polygram Copyright Buyout CF0893
$300,000,000 2002 Intergraph <-- Intel P.Settlement Electronics WSJ0402a
$300,000,000 1999 Univ. Minnesota <-- Glaxo Wellcome P.Settlement Drug WSJ1099
$300,000,000 1999 PGA <-- CBS C.License Sports BCB0698
$295,000,000 2003 Eli Lilly <-- Galen Holdings P.License Drugs GEN0103
$275,000,000 2000 Caldera <-- Microsoft Settlement Software NLJ01001
($270,000,000) 2000 Cordis/Johnson & Johnson <-- Medtronic P.Lawsuit Medical WSJ12002
$265,000,000 2002 Cadence Design Systems <-- Synopsys/Avant TradeSecret Software WSJ1102b
$225,000,000 2004 Intergraph <-- Intel P.Settlement Electronics SFC0403
$220,000,000 2001 FIFA <-- KirchMedia C.License Sports BW0602
$211,000,000 1996 Haworth <-- Steelcase P.Lawsuit Mechanical FOR0197
$205,000,000 1986 Hughes Tool <-- Smith International P.Lawsuit Mechanical CFO0489
$200,000,000 1999 Univ. California <-- Genentech P.Settlement Drugs SFC1194
$200,000,000 1990s Intel and AMD P.Wasted Electronics EBB0494
$200,000,000 2000 Gemstar <-- Motorola P.Settlement Electronics NLJ11001
$200,000,000 2000 Exelixis Pharmaceuticals <-- Bayer R&D Pact Drugs WSJ0100
$190,000,000 2005 HBO <- A&E C.License Television NYT0502
$187,000,000 1990s George Foreman <-- Salton Inc. T.License Endorsement SJMN0103
$187,000,000 2001 OSI Pharmaceuticals <-- Genentech,Roche P.License Drugs WSJ01011
$182,000,000 2001 Cadence Design Systems <-- Avant Trade Secret Software SFDJ0701
$175,000,000 2005 Taiwan Semiconductor <-- Semiconductor Manufacturing Trade Secret Electronics NLJ0502
$175,000,000 2002 Boston Scientific <-- Medtronic P.Settlement Medical NYT0902a
$174,000,000 [CKX +58%] 2005 19 Entertainment <-- CKX Inc. C.Buyout Television WSJ0503
$173,000,000 2005 Philip Morris <-- Otamedia T.Lawsuit Cigarettes WSJ05031
$170,000,000 2001 Gilead Sciences <-- OSI Pharmaceuticals P.Buyout Drug SFC1101
$170,000,000 2000 Kinetix Pharmaceuticals <-- Amgen Buyout Drugs GEN11001
$170,000,000 1998 Exxon Chemical <-- Mobil Chemical P.Lawsuit Chemical CHW0898
$169,000,000 2001 Boston Scientific <-- Medtronic P.Arbitrate Medical WSJ07011
$165,000,000 1999 Viskase Corp. <-- American National Can P.Lawsuit Chemicals NLJ04001
$163,500,000 1999 Procter & Gamble <-- Paragon Trade P.Settlement Mechanical WSJ0299
$158,000,000 2002 Guidant <-- Medtronic P.Lawsuit Medical NYT0402a
$154,000,000 1999 Hughes Aircraft <-- US Government P.Lawsuit Electronics Fed. Cl. No. 426-73
$150,000,000+ 2002 Intergraph <-- Intel P.Lawsuit Electronics WSJ1102d
$150,000,000 2002 Espirt de Corp. <-- Esprit Holdings T.Buyout Clothes SFC0202
$150,000,000 1997 Apple Computer <-- Microsoft License Software SM0997
($140,000,000) 2001 Guidant <-- St. Jude Medical P.Lawsuit Medical WSJ0701
$137,500,000 1999 George Foreman <-- T.Buyout Consumer NYT0602
$136,000,000 2002 RIAA <-- Media Group C.Lawsuit Music SFC0802
$135,000,000 2002 Genta <-- Aventis P.License Drugs WSJ0402b
$134,500,000 2004 Masimo <--Tyco Nellcor P.Lawsuit Medical KMOB news
$130,000,000 2004 Elan <-- Eisai P.Buyout Pharmaceuticals NYT0404
$130,000,000 2001 Warner Brothers <-- Walt Disney C.License Harry Potter NYT1101
$129,000,000 1994 Exxon Chemical <-- Lubrizol P.Lawsuit Chemical CHW0394
$127,000,000 1992 Honeywell <-- Minolta Camera License Electronic TBT0492
$125,000,000 1990 Procter & Gamble <-- P.Lawsuit Chemical AA0990
$118,000,000 2002 Bancorp Services <-- Hartford Ins. Trade Secret Business Method NLJ0302
$114,000,000 2002 Internet Magic <-- Netfax P.Lawsuit Software NLJ0202b
$112,000,000 2000 3Dfx <-- Nvidia Buyout Electronics SFC1200
$107,000,000 1992 3M <-- Johnson & Johnson P.Lawsuit Medical 22 USPQ2d 1401
$106,000,000 2013 Schlumberger <-- Ion Geophysical P.Lawsuit Engineering Law360, Feb 2013
$102,000,000 1997 Viskase <-- American National Can P.Lawsuit Mechanical BI0997
$100,000,000+ 2003 Celine Dion <-- Caesars Palace C.License Theater TIM0303
$100,000,000+ 2000 Chiron <-- Hoffman-LaRoche P.License Biotech BW0600
$100,000,000 2000 Pioneer HiBred <-- Cargill Trade Secrets Biotech NLJ0600
$100,000,000 1999 Inprise(Borland) <-- Microsoft License Software CRN0799
$100,000,000 2000 Abbott <-- Cephalon P.License Drugs GEN1100
$98,100,000 2002 B.J. Services <-- Halliburton P.Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0402a
$98,000,000 1997 Fonar Corp. <-- General Electric P.Lawsuit Electronics MHC0397
$96,000,000 2013 Syntrix Biosystems <-- Illumina P.Lawsuit Biotech Business Week, March 2013
$96,000,000 1997 U.S. Figure Skating <-- ABC C.License Sports BCB0698
$95,000,000 2010 SynQor <-- Artesyn et al. P.Lawsuit Electronic Law360, March 2013
$94,800,000 2005 Advanced Medical Optics <-- Alcon P.Lawsuit Medical NYT0505
$90,000,000 2003 Le Bron James <-- Nike T.License Signature WSJ0305
$90,000,000 1998 Sepracor <-- Eli Lilly P.License Drugs CEN1298
$90,000,000 1995 Wang <-- Microsoft License Software IW0495
$83,000,000 1994 Stac Electronics <-- Microsoft P.License Software CRN0694
$82,500,000 1994 Novell <-- Sun Microsystems Copyright Software CW0394
$80,000,000+ 2000 ETRI <-- Qualcomm P.Royalties Electronics WSJ1200
$80,000,000 2000 Avery Denison <-- Four Pillars Trade Secret Chemicals NLJ02003
$78,000,000 2004 Chiron <-- Roche Holdings P.Settlement Medical WSJ04091
$78,000,000 2001 Southern Clay Products <-- Sued-Chemie P.Lawsuit Chemicals IPT0301
$77,000,000 2000 Abgenix <-- ImmGenics Buyout Biotech GEN1000
$75,000,000 1998 Injection Research <-- Polaris Industries Trade Secret Fuel injection WSJ09011
$75,000,000 1996 Columbia/TriStar <-- USA Network C.License Television BCB0696
$72,700,000 1995 Stryker Corp. <-- Intermedics Orthopedics P.Lawsuit Medical USDC E.D.N.Y. No. CV-90-3006(ADS)(EDNY Oct. 3, 1995)
$70,000,000 1998 Odetics <-- Storage Technology P.Lawsuit Electronics ACCUSCAN
$68,750,000 2000 General Technology Apps. <-- Conoco Liquid Power P.Lawsuit Chemicals WP0500
$68,000,000 1997 Unocal <-- Six oil companies P.Lawsuit Chemical NPN1297
$65,000,000 2002 Polo Ralph Lauren <-- Jones Apparel Group C.License Clothing WSJ0203
$64,000,000 1998 Bourns <-- Raychem Antitrust Electronics BOURN
$64,000,000 1995 Schneider/BCSI <-- Scimed P.Lawsuit Medical BCSI
$63,500,000 2002 Aruze Corp. <-- Sammy Corp. P.Lawsuit Electronics IPT0602
$61,000,000 2002 Harris Corp. <-- Ericsson P.Lawsuit Electronics Dallas Business Journal 28 Nov 2002
$62,500,000 2003 Hilgraeve <-- Symantec P.Settlement Software WSJ0308
$60,000,000 2003 SPX Corp. <-- Microsoft P.Settlement Software NYT0312
$60,000,000 2005 Immersion <-- Sony P.Lawsuit Software NLJ0503
$60,000,000+ 1999 Ranbaxy Labs <-- Bayer AG License Drugs WSJ1299
$57,000,000 2002 Univ. Colorado <-- American Cyanamid P.Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0802a
$57,000,000 1997 Celeritas Tech. <-- Rockwell P.Lawsuit Electronics LAT0197
$55,000,000 2004 Elan <-- Vernalis P.Buyout Pharmaceuticals NYT0404
$55,000,000 2000 David Bowie <-- Prudential Insurance Copyright Music FOR0997
$53,000,000 2002 InterDigital Communications <-- NEC P.Settlement Electronics NYT0102a
$53,000,000 2000 Universal Music <-- MP3 C.License Music BW1100
$52,600,000 2002 Applera/MDS <-- Waters Corp. P.Lawsuit Chemical WSJ0502c
$52,600,000 2000 Caliper Technologies <-- Aclara Biosciences Trade Secrets Electronics WSJ10001
$51,000,000 2005 Medtronic <-- BrainLAB A.G. P.Lawsuit Medical NLJ0510
$50,000,000+ 2001 Bugle Boy Industries <-- Schottenstein Stores T.Buyout Trademark WSJ0801
$50,000,000 1994 Atari <-- Sega License Software IB0295
$50,000,000 1985 Apple Records <-- Michael Jackson C.Buyout Music
$50,000,000 1958 Paramount <-- MCA C.Buyout Movies BCB0602
$49,500,000 2003 Tulip Computers <-- Dell Computer P.Settlement Electronics http://www.detnews.com/2003/technology/0307
$48,000,000 1993 Eli Lilly <-- SciMed P.License Medical FW0493
$47,900,000 1999 AcroMed <-- Sofamor Danek P.Lawsuit Medical NLJ02002
$47,500,000 2002 Applied Biosystems/MDX <-- Micromass P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0402b
$46,580,000 2001 Honeywell <-- Hamilton Sundstrand P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ00301
$45,000,000 2000 Rodime <-- Seagate Technology Settlement Computers NLJ02003
$45,000,000 2000 Barr Laboratories <-- DuPont Settlement Drugs NLJ0200
$44,000,000 1995 Haworth <-- Herman Miller P.Lawsuit Mechanical FRB0596
$43,500,000 2004 Applied Medical Resources <-- Tyco U.S. Surgical P.Lawsuit Medical KMOB news
$40,000,000 [Ampex +90%] 2004 Ampex <-- Sony P.Settlement Software SFC0411
$40,000,000 2005 Soverain Software <-- Amazon P.Settlement Software NLJ0508
$40,000,000 2001 Lernout & Hauspie <-- ScanSoft P.Buyout Electronics NYT1101
($40,000,000) 1999 AccuScan <-- Xerox P.Lawsuit Electronics ACCUSCAN
$41,000,000 2000 Alexion Pharm. <-- Prolifaron Buyout Biotech GEN1000
$39,200,000 1998 AlliedSignal <-- Cooper Automotive P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0798
$39,000,000 2001 NEON Systems <-- New Era of Networks T.Lawsuit Trademark NLJ0701
($37,000,000) 2000 P.O. Market <-- Wal-Mart Trade Secrets Software WSJ0300
$36,500,000 2002 Atmel <-- Silicon Storage P.Lawsuit Electronics EN0502
($36,000,000) 1998 Interactive Tech. <-- Pittway/Ademco P.Lawsuit Electronics SDM0498
$35,000,000 2001 Crystal Semiconductor <-- Tritech Microelectronics P.Lawsuit Electronic CAFC0301
$35,000,000 2000 Caliper Technologies <-- Aclara Biosciences Trade Secrets Chemical REC1100
$35,000,000 1999 Angeion <-- Guidant License Medical ANGEION
$34,500,000 2001 Hybridon <-- Isis P.License Biotech GEN0601
$34,000,000 2003 InterDigital Comm. <-- Ericsson P.Settlement Electronics HR0303
$33,100,000 2002 Super Vision Int. <-- Jack Caruso TradeSecret Fiber optics NLJ1002
$32,600,000 2002 Bristol Myers Squibb <-- Aventis P.Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0802b
$32,400,000 2002 Misha Levy Defonesca <-- Mt.Ivy Press C.Lawsuit Book WSJ0402
$32,400,000 1996 SRI International <-- Advanced Technology Labs P.Lawsuit Electronics SRI
$32,300,000 1999 Power Integration <-- Motorola P.Lawsuit Electronics EET1099
$31,700,000 1999 Columbia Pictures <-- Krypton Broadcasting C.Lawsuit Television ELR0499
$30,200,000 2013 Seijiro Tomita <- Nintendo P.Lawsuit Software Wash.Post, 14 Mar 2013
$30,000,000 2002 eSpeed <-- CBOT and CME P.Settlement Software INT013
$30,000,000 2002 ADC Telecommunications <-- Thomas & Betts P.Settlement Electronics NLJ0502a
$30,000,000 2002 Michael Crichton <-- HarperCollins C.License Books NYT1102
$30,000,000 1998 Real 3D <-- Silicon Graphics License Software CRN1198
$24,000,000 2002 Unova <-- Broadcom P.Buyout Electronics NYT1202
$23,100,000 2002 NTP Inc. <-- Research in Motion P.Lawsuit Electronics WSJ1102a
$20,000,000 2003 Lowry's Reports <-- Legg Mason C.Lawsuit Newsletter NLJ0310
$20,000,000 1990 Rodime <-- IBM P.Settlement Mechanical EN1190
$29,000,000 1999 Int. Game Tech. <-- WMS Gaming P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ12991
$28,500,000+ 2002 InterTrust <-- Sony P.License Software WSJ0502b
$28,500,000 2002 Harry Gaus <-- Conair Corp. P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0202a
$27,200,000 2002 Inter. Rectifier <-- IXYS P.Lawsuit Electronics INT010
$26,000,000+ 2002 Cell Genesys <-- Transkaryotic Therapies P.License Drugs SFBJ0602
$26,000,000 2000 Simon Property Group <-- MySimon.com Trademark NLJ09001
$25,600,000 1990 Brooktree <-- AMD P.Lawsuit Electronics EN1090
$25,200,000 1999 Tec Air <-- Denso Manufacturing P.Lawsuit Chemical 52 USPQ2d 1294
$25,000,000 2003 St. Clair Intellectual Property <-- Sony P.Lawsuit Electronics news story
$25,000,000 2003 Nortel Networks <-- Ciena P.Settlement Electronics INT002
$25,000,000 2002 Fuji Photo Film <-- Jazz Photo P.Lawsuit Cameras NLJ1202
$25,000,000 2002 Fischer Imaging <-- Thermo Electron P.Settlement Medical PRNewswire
$25,000,000 2002 Honeywell <-- Borg Warner P.Lawsuit Mechanical WSJ0702
$25,000,000 2000 Lubrizol <-- Imperial P.Settlement Chemical NLJ11002
$25,000,000+ 2000 Bausch & Lomb <-- Alcon Laboratories P.Settlement Chemical CHW0200
$24,000,000 2002 Business Objects SA <-- Cognos P.Settlement Software WSJ0502d
$23,000,000 1985 Baker Hughes <-- Dresser Industries P.Settlement Mechanical FRB0790
$21,000,000 1993 Barr Laboratories <-- ICI License Chemical CHW0393
$20,000,000+ 2002 Varian Semiconductor <-- Lam Research P.Settlement Electronic EN0102
$20,000,000 2002 Mariah Carey <-- Universal Music Group C.Advance Music HR0502
$20,000,000 2002 Berlex Laboratories <-- Biogen P.Settlement Drugs NLJ0202
$20,000,000 2000 Tyson Foods <-- ConAgra Foods Trade Secrets Chemical WSJ1000
$20,000,000 2000 Xilinx <-- Altera P.Settlement Electronic SJMN0701
$20,000,000 1999 Crystal Semiconductor <-- Opti Inc. P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ02001
$19,000,000 2001 Brian Webster <-- 20th Century Fox C.Lawsuit Movie Script SFC0301
$18,000,000 2002 DepoMed <-- Bristol Myers Squibb P.Settlement Drugs INT012
$18,000,000 2000 Edmark Industries <-- S. Asia Intn'l P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0900
$18,000,000 1997 Comark Communications <-- Harris Corp. P.Lawsuit Electronics BCB0897
$18,000,000 2000 SIBIA <-- Cadus Pharmaceuticals P.Lawsuit Pharmaceutical NLJ1000
$18,000,000 2001 BioTime <-- Akzo Nobel P.License Pharmaceutical SFC0201
$17,530,000 2001 Osteotech <-- Gensci Regeneration P.Lawsuit Medical NLJ0102
$17,437,220 2002 BIC Corp. <-- ERA International P.Lawsuit Mechanical 00-CA-7155 (SDNY 27 Feb 2002)
$17,400,000 2002 X-IT Products <-- Walter Kidde P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0901
$17,200,000+ 2002 Alcon Inc <-- Nidek Co. P.Lawsuit Electronics INT004
$17,000,000 2003 TDK <-- Silicon Laboratories P.Settlement Electronics INT008
$17,000,000 1990 Modine Manufacturing <-- Allen Group P.Lawsuit Mechanical BAR1090
$16,640,000 2001 Valassis Communications <-- Dennis Garberg Trade Secret Business Data NLJ0102
$16,500,000 2001 F&G Scrolling Mouse <-- KeyTronic Trade Secret Electronic NYT1201
$16,350,000 2000 Integra Lifesciences <-- Merck KgaA P.Lawsuit Biotech NLJ10001
$16,000,000 2000 Eastern Michigan Univ. <-- ExxonMobil Patent Donation Chemicals NLJ05002
$15,800,000 2001 Ricoh <-- Nashua Corp. P.Settlement Mechanical NLJ01012
$15,000,000 2003 Interpore <-- Johnson & Johnson P.Settlement Medical NYT0103
$15,000,000 2002 3Com <-- Xircom P.Settlement Electronics WSJ1102e
$15,000,000 2002 Universal Pictures <-- USA/CBS/UPN C.License Movie HR0602
$15,000,000 2002 Jupiter Media Metrix <-- NetRatings P.Settlement Software WSJ0502
$15,000,000 2001 IPPV Enterprises <-- Echostar DISH P.Lawsuit Software NLJ0102
$15,000,000 2000 BroadVision <-- Art Technology Group Settlement Software NLJ0300
$14,400,000 2000 Coley Pharm. <-- Isis Pharm. Buyout Biotech GEN1000
$14,000,000 1993 Amgen <-- Genetics Institute P.License Biotech CMR0593
$13,700,000 1999 RIAA <-- Global Arts Production C.Lawsuit Music ELR1199
$13,200,000 2000 Frank Calabrese <-- Square D P.Lawsuit Software NYT0200
$13,000,000 2000 C.R. Bard <-- Boston Scientific P.Lawsuit Medical NLJ10001
$13,000,000 1998 Variable Parameter Fixture <-- Morpheus Lights P.Lawsuit Electronic S.D.N.Y case
$13,000,000 1997 Escom/Commodore <-- Gateway P.Buyout Electronic WSJ0899
$13,000,000 1997 Applied Medical Resources <-- US Surgical P.Lawsuit Medical HIT0797
$12,900,000 1999 General Surgical <-- Guidant P.Lawsuit Medical NLJ0800
$12,500,000 2005 Everlast Worldwide <-- Jacques Monet Int. T.License Clothing BTWO0505
$12,500,000 1999 Intermatic <-- Lamson & Sessions P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ1099
$12,500,000 1998 Interactive Networks <-- TCI P.Lawsuit Software BCB0398
$12,200,000 2003 Poly-America <-- GSE Lining Technology P.Lawsuit Mechanical INT007
$12,000,000 2003 Philip Jackson <-- Glenayre Electronics P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0403
$12,000,000 2000 Caliper Technologies <-- Flehr Hohbach TradeSecret Electronics REC1000
$11,750,000 2000 Heidelberg Harris <-- Mitsubishi Heavy Industry P.Lawsuit Mechanical Heidelberg v. Mitsubishi, 56 USPQ2d 1714
$11,700,000 2002 Alexis Leon <-- Nat. Lib. Ireland C.Buyout Book WSJ0502e
$11,000,000 2003 Tommy Hilfiger <-- Goody's Family Clothing T.Lawsuit Clothing NLJ0306
$11,000,000 2002 PEAT Inc. <-- Vanguard Research Trade Secret Engineering NLJ0802
$11,000,000 2000 Smith Engineering <-- Eisenmann Corp. P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ07000
$10,600,000 2001 Tanashin Denki v. Thomson Consumer Electronics P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ1101
$10,200,000 2000 Trident Microsystems <-- Via Technologies Settlement Electronics NLJ0500
$10,000,000 2002 Madonna <-- Microsoft C.License Music VAR0802
$10,000,000 2002 Syndia <-- Gillette P.Lawsuit Mechanical NYT0602a
$10,000,000 2002 Microsoft <-- Mr. Inder Deot C.Lawsuit Software SFC0602
$10,000,000 2000 ID Biomedical <-- Third Wave Tech. Settlement Biotech NLJ11002
$10,000,000 2000 Nycomed Imaging <-- Mallinckrodt Medical Settlement Medical NLJ05001
$10,000,000 2001 Nova Biomedical <-- i-STAT P.Settlement Medical IPT0901
$9,500,000 2002 iNTELEFILM <-- Walt Disney/ABC Trade Secret Business Method NLJ0502
$9,500,000 1999 Lucent <-- Newbridge Networks P.Lawsuit Electronics IPT0100
$9,500,000+ 1999 Syquest <-- Iomega Buyout Electronics BACC0199
$9,000,000 2000 Angeion <-- Medtronic License Medical ANGEION
$8,700,000 2001 William Riles <-- Shell Exploration P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ0401
$8,670,000 2004 Microtune <-- Broadcom P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0405
$8,500,000 2000 Celltech Group <-- Cistron Biotechnology Buyout Biotech GEN0400
$8,300,000 2001 Boston Scientific <-- Johnson & Johnson P.Lawsuit Medical WSJ0901
$8,000,000 [Miva +6.5%] 2005 Yahoo <-- Miva P.Settlement Software SFC0508
$8,000,000 2004 Novellus <-- Applied Materials P.Settlement Electronics WSJ0409
$8,000,000 2002 Charles Frazier <-- Random House C.Advance Book NYT0402
$8,000,000 2000 SanDisk < Lexar P.Settlement Electronics EN1100
$7,700,000 2000 Truck Stop Operator <-- Truck Stop Operator Copyright Floorplan CSE0900
$7,500,000 1993 Sepracor <-- Marion Merrell Dow Exclusive Rights Chemicals GEN0693
$7,400,000 2003 Ralph Benghiat <-- Itron Inc. P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0103
$7,400,000 2002 Telemac Corp. <-- USIntellicom P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0402
$7,100,000 2000 John Welch <-- Time Warner Books C.Advance Book DTN0700
$7,000,000 2001 Harris <-- Sanyo P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ1001
$7,000,000 2002 Liquid Audio <-- Microsoft P.Buyout Software SFC1002
$7,000,000 2000 GE Harris <-- Wabtec Settlement Electronics WSJ1100
$7,000,000 1985 Aerosmith <-- Geffen Records C.Advance Music Aerosmith
$6,700,000 2002 GTFM <-- Solid Clothing T.Lawsuit Clothing NLJ0702
$6,500,000 2000 Enzia Inc. <-- Accord Video Telecom Settlement Software NLJ07001
$6,300,000 2000 Dyson Appliances <-- Hoover P.Settlement Mechanical INT005
$6,000,000 2003 Proxim <-- Intersil P.Settlement Electronics INT009
$6,000,000 2001 Isis <-- Hybridon P.License Biotech GEN0601
$6,000,000 1995 Celeritas Tech. <-- ATT P.Lawsuit Electronics LAT0197
$5,700,000 2000 Bose <-- Harman Inter. P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ09001
$5,400,000 1999 Guidant <-- Medtronic P.Lawsuit Medical NLJ1299
$5,200,000 2001 Kipp Flores Architects <-- Signature Homes C.Lawsuit Architecture IPT0102
$5,000,000+ [Nastech +70%] 2004 Nastech <-- Merck P.Licence Pharmaceutical SFC0409
$5,000,000 2003 Michael Jackson <-- Fox Television C.License Television NYT0203
$5,000,000 2003 Grenada Television <-- ABC C.License Television CNN0203
$5,000,000 2000 M. Night Shyamalan <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$5,000,000 2001 Motorola <-- Nanogen P.Settlement Biotech NLJ0801
$5,000,000 2000 R.G. Barry Corp <-- Domino's Pizza Settlement Mechanical NLJ0400
$5,000,000 1999 Lucent Technologies <-- Ascend Communications License Electronics SJMN0199
$5,000,000 1996 Sony/Columbia <-- Turner Classic Movies C.License Movies BCB0896
$5,000,000 1980 Willemijn Holdings <-- IBM License Software CW0786
$4,900,000 2002 Macromedia <-- Adobe Systems P.Lawsuit Software SFC0502
$4,750,000 2002 300 musicians <-- Vivendi Universal C.Settlement Music SFC0102
$4,600,000 2001 Sonoco Products <-- competitor Trade Secret Mechanical NLJ04012
$4,500,000 2002 Microsoft <-- Lisa Chan C.Lawsuit Software SFC1102
$4,500,000 2002 Miramax Films <-- UPN Network C.License Movies VAR0502
$4,400,000 2002 Intuitive Surgical/IBM <-- Computer Motion P.Lawsuit Surgical NYT0802
$4,250,000 2000 Serta <-- Simmons P.Settlement Mechanical NLJ01011
$4,200,000 2002 MKS Instruments <-- Advanced Energy P.Lawsuit Chemical NLJ0602
$4,200,000 2001 Stephen L. Carter <-- Alfred A. Knopf C.Advance Book NYT0502a
$4,200,000 2000 Quickturn Design <-- Aptiz P.Lawsuit Legal fees NLJ09001
$4,000,000+ 2000 Baxter Intern. <-- Spectranetics Settlement Medical NLJ1100
$4,000,000 2002 Louis Gerstner <-- HarperCollins C.Advance Book NYT0502
$4,000,000 1995 Shane Black <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$4,000,000 2001 20th Century Fox <- Fox Broadcasting Copyright Movie BCB0101
$4,000,000 1991 Pharmacia AB <-- MedChem P.Lawsuit Chemical BBJ0191
$3,750,000 2002 Datascope <-- Vascular Solutions P.Settlement Medical INT011
$3,500,000 1992 Hilton Davis <-- Warner Jenkinson P.Lawsuit Chemical CMR0195
$3,500,000 2004 Golden Voice Technology <-- Rockwell Electronic P.lawsuit Software Web news
$3,500,000 1999 Varian Medical <-- David Kern Trade Secrets Electronics B20100
$3,100,000 1999 CFM Technologies <-- Steag Electronics P.Lawsuit Electronic EN1199
$3,000,000 2002 Emma McLaughlin, Nicola Kraus <-- Random House C.License Book DV0902
$3,000,000 2001 Sugar Hill Gang <-- Snapple Beverage/TBS C.Lawsuit Music WSJ1201
$3,000,000 2001 Carberry Corp. <-- Land O'Lakes Inc. P.Lawsuit Chemical NYT0102
$3,000,000 1999 Quickturn <-- Mentor Graphics Settlement Software EET0699
$3,000,000 1992 Joe Eszterhaus <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$2,820,000 2002 Adobe Systems <-- Macromedia P.Lawsuit Software SFC0502
$2,800,000 2001 Francis Crick <-- Wellcome Trust C.Buyout Papers NAT1201
$2,816,172 2002 Cincom Systems <-- Beckman Instruments C.Lawsuit Software Case no. SA CV 97-764 DOC (EEx), Central District California
$2,700,000 1999 SunTiger <-- Scientific Research Facility P.Lawsuit Optics BANWIT
$2,605,531 2000 Imageline <-- IMSI C.Lawsuit Digital Images Press Release"
$2,500,000 1969 Harold Robbins C.Advance Book in Timetables of History
$2,218,000 2000 Tate Access Floors <-- Maxcess Technologies P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ09002
$2,100,000 2002 Control Alt Design <-- Tensor Corp. P.Lawsuit Electronics NLJ0102a
$2,000,000 2002 Digimarc <-- Verance P.Settlement Software Digimarc
$2,000,000 2002 nCube <-- SeaChange International P.Lawsuit Electronics ZDNET
$2,000,000 2000 Lexar < SanDisk P.Settlement Electronics EN1100
$2,000,000 2001 Lamps Plus <-- Catalina Lighting P.Lawsuit Mechanical NLJ04012
$2,000,000 2000 Novell <-- Myung Je Copyright Software NLJ10001
$2,000,000+ 1999 Lonnie Johnson <-- Laramie Ltd. Royalties Mechanical LAT0799
$2,000,000 1995 Joe Eszterhaus <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$1,900,000 2003 Mattel <-- Safety1st/Dorel P.Lawsuit Mechanical NYT0103a
$1,800,000/year 2013 Google Motorola Mobility <-- Microsoft P.Lawsuit Telecom Bloomberg, 26 Apr 2013
$1,800,000 2005 Univ. Texas <-- RIM P.Settlement Software SCI0508
$1,800,000 2002 David Benioff <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$1,750,000 1991 Shane Black <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$1,500,000 2003 Clarence Thomas <-- Harper-Collins C.Advance Book NYT0103b
$1,500,000 2001 Acres Gaming <-- Mikohn Gaming P.Lawsuit Software NLJ04011
$1,450,000 1999 Freeman <-- First Years Settlement Mechanical NLJ0100
$1,400,000 2001 Internet Pictures <-- iMove Inc. P.Lawsuit Software IntPic
$1,350,000 2002 9 coal miners <-- Walt Disney C.License TV/books NYT0802a
$1,300,000 1980 Laurie Visual <-- Chesebrough-Pond P.Lawsuit Mechanical BW1180
$1,250,000 2002 Ryder System <-- Budget Group T.Settlement Trademark WSJ1102
$1,250,000 1998 Eaton <-- Meritor Automotive P.Lawsuit Mechanical FLO0898
$1,230,000 1998 Samuel Zervitz <-- Hollywood Pictures C.Lawsuit MovieScript ELR1098
$1,200,000 2002 SESAC <-- WPNT Inc. C.Lawsuit Music law.com article
$1,015,180 2001 Micro Chemical <-- Lextron P.Lawsuit Software NLJ07011
$1,000,000+ 2002 Beatles music owner <-- H&R Block C.Royalty Music CBS2002
$1,000,000 2002 Storage Engine <-- Veritas Software P.Buyout Software INT003
$1,000,000 2002 RIAA <-- Integrated Info. Sys. C.Settlement Music FOR0602
$1,000,000 2001 Great Lakes Chemical <-- Archimica P.Lawsuit Pharmaceutical NLJ0201
$1,000,000 2000 National Instruments <-- PPT Vision Settlement Software NLJ07001
$1,000,000 1999 Interactive Pictures <-- Infinite Pictures P.Lawsuit Software BANWIT
$1,000,000 1990 Brian Helgeland <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$1,000,000 1990 Kathy McWorter <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$1,000,000 1939 Philo Farnsworth <-- RCA Victor P.Settlement Electronics SFC0902
$700,000 2002 Claudia Schiffer <-- Hello magazine C.License Photographs SFC0502a
$680,000 2003 Novell <-- Computer Commodity C.Lawsuit Software WSJ0503
$650,000+ 2000 CoolSavings <-- e-centives Settlement Software IPT1100
$629,000 2005 Mag Instrument <-- Ikea T.Lawsuit Flashlight BTWO0505
$564,000 2002 Texto <-- Nike T.Lawsuit Footwear OREG0202
$500,000 2003 Mohammed Odeh al-Rehaief <-- HarperCollins C.Advance Book NYT0503
$500,000 2002 Alisa Valdes-Rodriguez <-- St. Martin's Press C.Advance Book SFC0702
$480,000 2001 BSA <-- ThoughtWorks C.Piracy Software WSJ01012
$400,000 1973 Stephen King <-- Signet Books C.Advance Book RDI0101
$400,000 1969 William Goldman <-- 20th Century Fox C.License Script INT001
$250,000 1987 Shane Black <-- C.License Script NYT1201a
$71,000 2002 Ludlow Music <-- Robbie Williams C.Lawsuit Music SJMN0202
$25,000 1953 ATT Bell Labs <-- Sony P.License Electronics BW0407


$500,000,000/year 1999 Semiconductor IP Royalties Electronics EN1200
$50,000,000/year 1990s SanDisk Corp. Royalties Electronics EN0400
$5,000,000/year 1990s Univ. Penn. <-- Genovo Excl.Rights Biotech SFC0500
$5-10,000,000/year 1990s Advanced RISC Machines Royalties Electronics EB1099
$0.25/system 1999 1394 Bus Patent Pool Royalties Electronics EET0299
$65.00/video < 1997 Disney <-- Blockbuster Royalties Movies NYT0103c
$7.00/unit 2000 Palm <-- Handspring Royalties Software FOR0501
$0.075/CD track NMPA <-- Music Industry Royalties Music FOR0601
$2000+/second 2000s NFL Royalties Television WSJ0103
11% of gross 2003-4 RIAA etc. <-- Webcasters Music WSJ0403
7% of gross 2000s RIAA/AFTRA/RFM <-- MusicChoice/DMX/Muzak Music HR0203
3% of gross 2001 Eidos Royalties Copyright WSJ06011
2% of gross 2001 Fraunhofer Institute MP3 streaming WRD0901
0.50/player 2001 Fraunhofer Institute MP3 decoding WRD0901
NOTE: Fraunhofer Institute and the Thomson Corporation have a Web site where there is lots of information about MP3 and how to license the technology.

REFERENCES

AA0990 - "P&G Food Unit Back in the Black", Advertising Age, 17 September 1990, 16

AWST0993 - "Litton wins $1.2 billion in laser gyro patent suit", Aviation Week & Space Technology, 6 September 1993, 29; however on 9 January 1995, district judge Mariana Pfaelzer overturned the jury verdict of August 1993, declaring a Litton reissue patent invalid. See also a Federal Circuit decision, 238 F.3d 1376. However, in 2001, Honeywell agreed to settle the matter for $420,000,000. See "Honeywell is in settlement with Northrup", New York Times, 22 December 2001, C4.

B20100 - "007 to 10", Business 2.0, January 2000, 34

BACC0199 - "Iomega buys Syquest Inventory, Patents", Bay Area Computer Currents, 26 January 1999, 13

BAR1090 - "Allen Group: Cost-cutting Puts Parts-Maker on Recovery's Road", Barron's, 8 October 1990, 47

BBJ0191 - "MedChem wins battle, loses patent", Boston Business Journal, 21 January 1991, 1

BCB0602 - "Editorials - Visionary", Broadcasting & Cable, 10 June 2002, 42 (mentions how Lew Wasserman's agency, MCA, bought Paramount's pre-1948 theatrical library for $50,000,000, and also bought the Universal lot for $12,000,000)

BCB0101 - "Fox gets 'Sound of Music' rights for $4,000,000", Broadcasting & Cable, 1 January 2001, 37 - movie rights are for five years

BCB1000 - "Fox crowds the plate", Broadcasting & Cable, 2 October 2000 (10-2-00), 8

BCB0698 - "Sports Rights Scorecard", Broadcasting & Cable, 22 June 1998, 34 (US Figure Skating deal was for 1999 to 2006 at $12 million/year; PGA deal with CBS was for 1999 to 2001 at $100 million/year; ABC paid college football $500 million for the 1998 to 2004 bowl game broadcasts; in 1995 CBS paid the NCAA $1.725 billion for college basketball finals for 1996 to 2002;

BCB0398 - "TCI settles interactive net suit", Broadcasting & Cable, 9 March 1998, 58

BCB0897 - "Comark wins more money from Harris", Broadcasting & Cable, 4 August 1997, 50

BCB0896 - "TCM gets rights to Sony-owned Columbia classic movies", Broadcasting & Cable, 19 August 1996, 61 (Turner licenses broadcast rights for 3 years for 36 vintage Columbia films)

BCB0696 - "USA pays $75 million for 'Walker'", Broadcasting & Cable, 10 June 1996, 44 (USA Network licenses off-network rights to "Walker, Texas Ranger")

BCB0194 - "Another Olympic win for CBS", Broadcasting & Cable, 24 January 1994, 10 (CBS pays rights to 1998 Winter Olympics)

BCB0993 - "Turner gets four more years of roundball", Broadcasting & Cable, 27 September 1993, 28

BI0997 - "CGL doesn't cover patent award", Business Insurance, 8 September 1997, 14

BTWO0505 - A Swedish court rules Ikea copied Mag Instrument's Maglite flashlight. Everlast Worldwide makes boxing equipment that appeared in the movie "Million Dollar Baby", and signs a five year licensing deal for women's apparel. Business 2.0, May 2005, 140.

BW1180 - "The case that is scuttling the patent pirates", Business Week, 10 Nov 1980, 136

BW0600 - "Why Chiron may be on the mend", Business Week, 26 June 2000, 254; also "Rift with Roche is settled on diagnostic technology", Wall Street Journal, 12 October 2000, B10

BW1100 - "MP3.com signs a peace treaty", Business Week, 27 Nov 2000, 66

BW0602 - "World Cup: sponsors need to get in the Game", Business Week, 17 June 2002, 52 (FIFA Feder. Inter. Football Assoc. sells U.S. broadcast rights for World Cup to KirchMedia for $220 million)

BW0802 - John Osher and three colleagues in 1999 invent a $5 electric toothbrush. In 2001, they sell the rights to P&G for $165 million upfront, plus future payments. In 2002, they settle for a final additional payment of $310,000,000. Business Week, 12 Aug 2002, 58

BW0407 - Akio Morita and Masaru Ibuka, seven years after starting what was to become Sony, licenses the transistor technology from Bell Labs, and four years later introduces a portable electronic radio. Business Week, 26 July 2004, 14.

CAFC0301 - U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, case 99-1558, 99-1559, 00-1006

CBS2002 During a 7 April 2002 CBS Marketwatch interview, H&R Block CEO Mark Ernst stated that H&R Block paid over $1,000,000 to use the Beatles song "Taxman" in their advertisements

CEN1298 - "Eli Lilly moves to protect lucrative Prozac franchise", Chemical & Engineering News, 12 December 1998, 14

CF0893 - "PolyGram's $300m for soul rights to Motown", Corporate Finance, August 1993, 3

CFO0489 - "War and Peace in the Oil Patch", CFO, April 1989, 36; also "Mission Mistaken", Financial World, 31 May 1988, 16

CHW0200 - "Enzyme spat settled", Chemical Week, 9 February 2000

CHW0898 - "Jury bills Mobil $171 million for infringing Exxon patent", Chemical Week, 19 August 1998, 18

CHW0394 - "Judge boosts Exxon award to $129 million", Chemical Week, 2 March 1994, 9; also "Lube additives: $48-million jury award to Exxon", Chemical Week, 1 December 1993, 13

CHW0393 - "ICI pays Barr in Nolvadex settlement", Chemical Week, 17 March 1993, 13

CMR0593 - "Genetics Institute settles with Amgen in EPO dispute", Chemical Marketing Reporter, 24 May 1993, 17

CMR0195 - "Landmark dye patent case nears", Chemical Marketing Reporter, 9 January 1995, 4

CNN0203 - ABC pays nearly $5,000,000 to Grenada for their documentary interview of Michael Jackson to be broadcast on ABC's show 20/20. Associated Press 7 Feb 2003

CRN0799 - "Throwing its money around", Computer Reseller News, 5 July 1999, pages 91-92

CRN1198 - "Silicon Graphics, Real 3D close rift", Computer Reseller News, 9 November 1998, 214

CRN0694 - "Microsoft to pay $83M to settle Stac compression suit", Computer Reseller News, 27 June 1994, 7

CSE0900 - "Copyright - and value - of design upheld by jury", Consulting Specifying Engineer, Sep 2000, 27

CW0394 - "Sun, Novell strike Unix royalty deal", Computerworld, 21 March 1994, 4

CW0786 - "Token-Ring Net Developer Strives to Enforce Patent Protection", Computerworld, 7 July 1986, 90

DTN0700 - "GE chairman Welch gets $7.1 million book deal", Detroit News, 15 July 2000

DV0401 - "Crown pays $820 million for 700 Hallmark titles", Daily Variety, 16 April 2001, 3

DV0902 - "'Nanny' duo books $3 million", Daily Variety, 27 September 2002, 5 - two authors get $3 million for the North American rights to their next two books

EB1099 - "ARMing the world - royalties on a roll", Electronic Business, November 1999, 60

EBB0494 - "How Intel and AMD wasted more than $200,000,000", Electronic Business Buyer, April 1994, 38

EET0299 - "Licensing deal calls for 1394 patent pool", Electronic Engineering Times, 22 Feb 1999, 8

EET0699 - "Mentor, Quickturn settle patent suit", Electronic Engineering Times, 28 June 1999, 8

EET1099 - "Power IC house wins suit versus Motorola", Electronic Engineering Times, 25 October 1999, 8; also "Motorola loses patent battle", National Law Journal, 1 Nov 1999, B17. See also NLJ02002. In a confidential statement, the case was settled for a much lower amount.

EET1290 - "TI, Toshiba pact includes Kilby patents", Electronic Engineering Times, 17 December 1990, 4 (Toshiba and TI sign 10-year cross licensing agreement, plus Toshiba will pay royalty on a percentage of its worldwide sales, upwards of $75 million a year for the next ten years. See also "Toshiba will pay for TI patent use", Electronic New, 17 December 1990, 30)

ELR0499 - "Aspiring screenwriter wins $1.23 million judgment against Hollywood Pictures and Interscope in case asserting that 'The Air Up There' infringed copyright to writer's six-page movie synopsis", Entertainment Law Reporter, October 1998, 10

ELR0499 - "Jury awards Columbia Pictures $31.7 million verdict in copyright infringement case against television station that continue to broadcast programs after Columbia terminated license for non-payment of license fees", Entertainment Law Reporter, April 1999, 18

ELR1199 - "Recording industry wins permanent injunction and then $13.7 million judgment against international music pirate", Entertainment Law Reporter, November 1999, 21

EN1090 - "AMD ordered to pay $25.6 million to Brooktree in patent case", Electronic News, 1 October 1990, 8

EN1190 - "IBM to pay Rodime", Electronic News, 5 November 1990, 1

EN1199 - "Court upholds ruling on Steag Infringement", Electronic News, 15 November 1999, 11

EN0400 - "SanDisk wins lawsuit against Lexar", Electronic News, 10 April 2000, 50

EN1100 - "Peace at last: Lexar and SanDisk settle", Electronic News, 20 November 2000, 2

EN1200 - "IP industry surpassed $500M in 1999" Electronic News, 4 Dec 2000, 12

EN0102 - "Varian and Lam settle lawsuit", Electronic News, 7 January 2002, 22 (Lam pays Varian $20M and also issue a warrant for the purchase of 2 million shares of Lam common stock)

EN0502 - "Jury awards Atmel $20M for SST patent infringement", Electronic News, 6 May 2002, 20 (patents were 4,511,811 and 4,673,829); "Atmel says court awards $36.5 million in patent claim", Semiconductor Business News, 10 May 2002 (the judge increased the jury's verdict award due to willful infringement and pre-judgment interest) www.semibiznews.com/story/OEG20020510S0050

FLO0898 - "Meritor ESS design infringes on Eaton patent", Fleet Owner, August 1998, 14

FOR0602 - "After Napster", Fortune, 34 June 2002 (RIAA gets $1,000,000 from Integrated Information Systems, whose employees who down load and share copyrighted music on IIS' corporate servers)

FOR0601 - "The music men are out of tune", Fortune, 11 June 2001, 144; the National Music Publishers Association collects $0.075 for every music track sold on a compact disk.

FOR0501 - "Has Palm lost its grip?", Forbes, 28 May 2001, 108; "Handspring licenses the Palm operating system, so Palm makes about $9 in royalties on every Visor sold."

FOR0997 - "Rock-star bonds", Forbes, 22 September 1997, 170

FOR0197 - "Sweet Justice", Forbes, 27 January 1997, 14; of the $211 million, $86 million was the original award, the rest pre- and post- judgment interest.

FRB0596 - "You say 65% off, they say 71%", Forbes, 20 May 1996, 164

FRB0790 - "Hot potato?", Forbes, 9 July 1990, 38 (Dresser settles patent suit with Baker, paying Baker $23 million plus its 28% stake in a joint venture)

FW0493 - "Flying fists", Financial World, 27 April 1993, 62

GEN0693 - "Collaborations & Agreements", Genetic Engineering News, 15 June 1993, 17

GEN0400 - "Collaborations & Agreements", Genetic Engineering News, 1 April 2000, 44

GEN1000 - "Collaborations & Agreements", Genetic Engineering News, 15 October 2000, 5 & 55

GEN1100 - "Collaborations & Agreements: Abbott Laboratories", Genetic Engineering News, 15 November 2000, 52

GEN11001 - "Collaborations & Agreements: Amgen", Genetic Engineering News, 1 November 2000, 5

GEN0601 - "Collaborations & Agreements: Hybridon and Isis", Genetic Engineering News, 15 June 2001, 5; Isis will pay Hybridon $15 million in cash and will pay $19.5 million in Isis stock over two years for Hybridon's antisense IP, while Hybridon will pay Isis $6 million in Hybridon stock over three years for Isis's RNase H technology

GEN0103 - Galen is licensing the US sales and marketing rights to Lilly's Sarafem drug for pre-menstrual dysphoric disorder Genetic Engineering News, 1 Jan 2003, 5

HIT0797 - "Applied Medical buoyed by verdict over U.S. Surgical patent dispute", Health Industry Today, July 1997, 2

HR0502 - "Carey signs for $20 mil revival, own UMG label", Hollywood Reporter, 9 May 2002, 1; Carey gets $20 mil to produce three albums with an option for a fourth

HR0602 - "'Scorpion' rights go to three nets", Hollywood Reporter, 11 June 2002, 56; (Universal Pictures sells television rights to 'The Scorpion King' to USA Networks/CBS/UPN for over $15 million)

HR0203 - "Music labels, groups ink royalty deal", Hollywood Reporter, 7-9 Februrary 2003, page 29; music subscription services Music Choice, DMX Music and Muzak will pay the music rights groups RIAA, AFTRA and AFM royalties for broadcasting music as follows: 7% of gross income for the years 2002 and 2003, and 7.25% for the years 2004 to 2007, plus a $100,000/year minimum fee.

IB0295 - "Hedgehog and Jaguar", International Business, February 1995, 70

INT001 - 20th Century Fox pays William Goldman $400,000 for script for the movie Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid.

INT002 - RCR News, 24 Jan 2003.

INT003 - E-commerce Times, 2 Aug 2002

INT004 - Judge rules Nidek infringed Alcon's excimer laser patents, and ordered payment of $14.8 million for lost profits and $2.4 million for royalties on past sales, plus 5% royalty on all sales after January 2001. Dallas Business Journal, 27 Sep 2002

INT005 - High Court in London rules in Hoover infringed Dyson's vacuum cleaner patent. BBC, 3 Oct 2000

INT006 - In Sept. 2002, Judge Robert Whaley enters final judgment for Medical Instruments in San Diego Federal Civil Case No. 97-2271

INT007 - A jury ruled in favor of Poly-America over plastic liners for landfills. The patents at issue were 5,763,047 and 5,804,112. Additional information

INT008 - The patent at issue involved technology for transmitting a signal across a chip using capacitors. Additional information

INT009 - The two companies dropped all lawsuits and agreed to cross-license some technology. Additional information

INT010 - Additional information

INT011 - Additional information

INT012 - Additional information

INT013 - CBOT and CME each paid $15,000,000 to eSpeed. Additional information

IPT1100 - "CoolSavings and e-centives settle patent infringement suits", Intellectual Property Today, November 2000, 14

IPT0100 - "Jury upholds Lucent patents against Newbridge Networks", Intellectual Property Today, January 2000, 10; also "BYTES: Switched Off; Heartened", National Law Journal, 6 December 1999, B7

IPT0301 - "Southern Clay wins one of the largest ever patent infringement judgments", Intellectual Property Today, March 2001, 12; see also "Multimillion dollar jury verdict for infringement", National Law Journal, 19 June 2000, B14

IPT0901 - "i-STAT and Nova Biomedical settle patent litigation", Intellectual Property Today, September 2001, 12

IPT0102 - "Architectural copycats feel the impact of obscure law", Intellectual Property Today, January 2002, 19

IPT0602 - "Record setting patent infringement damages award in Japan", Intellectual Property Today, June 2002, 15 (Aruze sued Sammy and Net Co. over slot machine control patent - Sammy will pay 7.4 billion yen and Net Co. will pay 1.0 billion yet)

IW1197 - "Digital, Intel settle suits", Informationweek, 3 November 1997, 34

IW0495 - "Microsoft and Wang strike accord", Informationweek, 24 April 1995, 15

LAT0197 - "Irvine firm may get $57 million in Rockwell suit", Los Angeles Times, 1 January 1997, D1

LAT0799 - "Little squirt turns big shot", Los Angeles Times, 29 July 1999, A1

LAT1202 - "KirchMedia gets Paramount's film library", Los Angeles Times, 13 December 2002, C4 - KirchMedia pays $500 million for the rights to Paramount Picture's film library through 2011.

MHC0397 - "GE must pay $98 million for patent infringement", Modern Healthcare, 3 March 1997, 28

NAT1201 - "Wellcome bid sees Crick archive return home", Nature, 13 December 2001, 678 (archive includes his papers, correspondences and laboratory notebooks)

NLJ0798 - "Spark-plug innovation ignites patent dispute", National Law Journal, 20 July 1998, A8

NLJ1099 - "Plaintiff wins $12.5 in patent infringement suit", National Law Journal, 25 October 1999, B8

NLJ1299 - "BYTES: Switched Off; Heartened", National Law Journal, 6 December 1999, B7

NLJ12991 - "BYTES: Played Out", National Law Journal, 27 December 1999, B7

NLJ0100 - "BYTES: Cup and Lip", National Law Journal, 17 January 2000, B6

NLJ01001 - "Microsoft's 'other' case settles fast", National Law Journal, 24 January 2000, A9

NLJ0200 - "BYTES: Blood war (anti-trust settlement between DuPont and Barr Labs)", National Law Journal, 07 February 2000, B7

NLJ02001 - "It was not crystal clear who the inventor was", National Law Journal, 28 February 2000, C21

NLJ02002 - "Copying medical devices proved irrestible" and "Chipping away at rival's patent can cost big bucks", National Law Journal, 28 February 2000, C10

NLJ02003 - "BYTES: Espionage; Settlement", National Law Journal, 21 February 2000, B6; for Avery Dennison, see also "Accusations stick in the adhesive industry", National Law Journal, 19 February 2001, C15 which reports that original $40 million judgement increased to $80 million

NLJ0300 - "Settlement on technology for sniffing out e-buyers",National Law Journal, 13 March 2000, B9

NLJ0400 - "Hot Dispute",National Law Journal, 17 April 2000, B6

NLJ04001 - "Big Wins",National Law Journal, 24 April 2000, B18,B19

NLJ0500 - "International Peace",National Law Journal, 8 May 2000, B6

NLJ05002 - "Move over Mr. Carnegie - make way Mr. Mellon",National Law Journal, 8 May 2000, B9

NLJ05001 - "All clear",National Law Journal, 22 May 2000, B6; see also a Mallinckrodt press release

NLJ0600 - "Dispute over engineered crops is settled in Iowa", National Law Journal, 05 June 2000, B11

NLJ07000 - "LA jury awards $11M in patent infringement suit", National Law Journal, 3 July 2000, A13

NLJ07001 - "Visionary system proves less than visionary", National Law Journal, 3 July 2000, B11; and "Three year moratorium for battling tech manufacturers"

NLJ0800 - "Appeals court deflates Guidant's damages", National Law Journal, 14 August 2000, B12 (CAFC throws out $12.9 million award against Guidant that San Jose jury had awarded in 1999 trial)

NLJ0900 - "Slice-and-dice patent feud results in $18M award", National Law Journal, 4 September 2000, A11

NLJ09001 - "Jury awards big bucks, but will the judge agree?", National Law Journal, 25 September 2000, B10; also "Harman will alter its sound to appease Bose's fury", "Aptix must pay 'needless' costs of dismissed case"

NLJ09002 - "Federal Circuit upholds jury's finding in floor case", National Law Journal, 4 September 2000, B8

NLJ1000 - "Win goes sour for biotech firm", National Law Journal, 2 October 2000, B12 (CAFC throws out $18 million jury award against Cadus).

NLJ10001 - "Novell wins copyright suit over bootleg copies", "Patent case over medical device settled", and "Patent infringement award upheld by federal judge", National Law Journal, 23 October 2000, B8

NLJ1100 - "Spectranetics will pay Baxter for surgical lasers", National Law Journal, 20 November 2000, B10

NLJ11001 - "BYTES - TV peace", National Law Journal, 13 November 2000, B8

NLJ11002 - "Solid settlement garners Lubrizol some liquid assets" and "3d Wave's genial but costly settlement for Invader suit", National Law Journal, 6 November 2000, B12

NLJ01011 - "BYTES - Right to yawn four", National Law Journal, 15 January 2001, B8

NLJ01012 - "In the business of copying, but not quite that way", National Law Journal, 22 January 2001, B8

NLJ0201 - "Plaintiff gets $13 million less than what it asked for", National Law Journal, 19 February 2001, B7; also "Great Lakes, Clariant settle suit", Chemical Week, 14 Feb 2001, 28; Archimica is now known as Clariant Life Science Molecules

NLJ0301 - "$46M for infringement on air flow patents [to Honeywell]", National Law Journal, 19 March 2001, A14

NLJ0401 - "Shell Exploration hit with $8.7 infringement verdict", National Law Journal, 2 April 2001, B6

NLJ04011 - "Jackpot Jury", National Law Journal, 16 April 2001, B3

NLJ04012 - "Record supported $4.6M award in paper tube case", National Law Journal, 30 April 2001, B6; and "Counterclaim nets $2M verdict for infringement", B7

NLJ0701 - "Jury awards $39M for infringement of 'Neon'", National Law Journal, 23 July 2001, B4

NLJ07011 - "Jury awards more than $1M in infringement case", National Law Journal, 30 July 2001, B4

NLJ0801 - "In Brief: Patent Infringement", National Law Journal, 20 August 2001, A19

NLJ0901 - "Climbing a ladder to $116 Million", National Law Journal, 3 September 2001, A4; $21 million in compensatory and $95 million in punitives for fire escape ladder; however, a judge later reduced the award to $18 million - see National Law Journal, 29 July 2002, A6 "A judge makes $100M disappear"

NLJ09011 - "Engine-part suit settles for $75 million plus", C6; "$18.5 million award over blanket patent reversed", C7; National Law Journal, 3 September 2001

NLJ1001 - "Harris Corp. wins $7M in royalties from Sanyo", National Law Journal, 8 October 2001, B5 (patent for television closed captioning)

NLJ1101 - "Thomson liable for $10.6M", National Law Journal, 12 November 2001, A18 (patent for casette tape player components)

NLJ0102 - "Big verdicts of 2001 went as high as $140 million", 21 January 2002, C5; "$17.53 million for maker of bone growth products", "$16.64 million for trade secrets misappropriation", "$15 million in case over pay-per-view patents" NLJ0102a - "Tensor to pay $2.1M for copying computer lamp", National Law Journal, 14 January 2002, B4

NLJ0202 - "Biogen settlement", National Law Journal, 4 February 2002, A19

NLJ0202a - "Jury blows away Conair with $28.5 million infringement award", National Law Journal, 11 February 2002, B1 (handheld hair dryer safety device); (upheld in 2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 1445)

NLJ0202b - "Netfax to pay $114 million for infringing rival's patent", National Law Journal, 18 Februrary 2002, B1 ($12.4 million for breaching confidentiality, $1.6 million on misapropriation of trade secrets, and $100 million in punitive damages)

NLJ0302 - "Missouri jury awards $118 million", National Law Journal, 25 March 2002, A25 ($100,408,000 for breach of contract, and $17,930,000 for misappropriation)

NLJ0402 - "7.4 million for stealing idea for cellphone system", National Law Journal, 1 April 2002, B4

NLJ0402a - "Halliburton hit for $98.1 million", National Law Journal, 22 April 2002, B1

NLJ0402b - "$47.5 million awarded in scientific infringement", National Law Journal, 29 April 2002, B4

NLJ0502 - "IN BRIEF: Disney Hit", National Law Journal, 20 May 2002, A25

NLJ0502a - "IN BRIEF: $30M patent win", National Law Journal, 11 May 2002, A15

NLJ0602 - "Infringement suit costs firm $4.2 million", National Law Journal, 17 June 2002, B2 (Delware jury verdict over patent for dissociating gases used in semiconductor processing)

NLJ0702 - "IN BRIEF: Infringement", National Law Journal, 11 July 2002, A19 (GTFM gets $6.7 million from competitor for trademark infringement of clothing)

NLJ0802 - "IN BRIEF: Trade Secret Theft", National Law Journal, 5 August 2002, A19 (PEAT gets $325,000 in compensatory, $1.8 million in actual and $8.8 million in punitive damages for technology involving plasma-energy waste disposal)

NLJ0802a - "IN BRIEF: American Cyanamid Hit", National Law Journal, 19 August 2002, A6 (American Cyanamid falsely reclaimed invention of a reformulation of a vitamin actually done by two professors at the University of Colorado, who were awarded $1,000,000)

NLJ0802b - "Judge imposes $32M fee award", National Law Journal, 5 August 2002, A21 (Aventis had sued Bristol Myers and lost when the court ruled the patent unenforceable because Rhone-Poulenc (which merged with Hoechst to form Aventis) withheld information from the PTO. Aventis' behavior was so vexatious that the judge ordered Aventis to pay the BMS for its attorney and expert witness fees.

NLJ1002 - "Fiber optics firm wins trade secret suit", National Law Journal, 7 October 2002, B1

NLJ1202 - "$25 million award in Fuji camera case", National Law Journal, 16 December 2002, B1

NLJ0103 - Jury find Itron infringed Benghiat's patent for algorithm for utility meter reading. The amount is based on an expert-established royalty rate of 5.25%. A willfulness finding also allows Benghiat to collect more than $1,000,000 in attorney fees. National Law Journal, 13 Jan 2003, B1

NLJ0403 - "Inventor of voice mail access wins patent claim", National Law Journal, 21 April 2003; Glenayre first sued for declaratory judgment, and the Jackson countersued for infringement.

NLJ0306 - Goody's was selling knock-offs of Hilfiger's jeans and T-shirts, making a profit of $8.97 million on the jeans and $690,000 on the T-shirts, for sales in 1999 and 2000. National Law Journal, 9 June 2003, 36.

NLJ0310 - Investment banker Legg Mason illegally redistributed copies of Lowry's Reports' financial newsletter. National Law Journal, 20 October 2003, 8.

NLJ0405 - A jury rules that Broadcom infringed Microtune's patent on television tuners. The $8.67 million judgment comprises $3 million in penalties and $5.6 million in attorney fees and costs. National Law Journal, 10 May 2004, 16.

NLJ0502 - Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing and Shanghai-based Semiconductor Manufacturing International settle lawsuits before the U.S. International Trade Commission and a Taiwan district court. National Law Journal, 7 February 2005, 16.

NLJ0502 - Immersion had two patents on tactile feedback devices that were being infringed by Sony's PlayStation console and DualShock controllers. The jury awarded $82 million, and the judge added $8.7 million in interest. National Law Journal, 29 March 2005, 9.

NLJ0510 - Medtronic Navigation sued BrainLAB A.G. in 1998 over four patents for image-guided surgical devices. A jury verdict awarded Medtronic the $51 million. National Law Journal, 10 October 2005, 16.

NLJ0508 - The companies settled a lawsuit involving Soverain's patents on network sales and Internet server access control and monitoring. National Law Journal, 15 August 2005, 16.

NYT0200 - "A poignant case of a patent", New York Times, 6 February 2000, Money & Business Section, page 2

NYT1101 - "Buyers of units of Lernout are disclosed", New York Times, 29 November 2001, C3 (Lernout sold speech technology assets while in bankruptcy)

NYT1101a - "Disney acquires the rights to broadcast Potter films", New York Times, 30 November 2001, C2 (Disney pays $70 million for cable and TV rights to the first Harry Potter movie, and $60 for the second movie)

NYT1201 - "Keytronic verdict may put it in default", New York Times, 22 December 2001, C2

NYT1201a - "Screenwriters adjust to being bit players again", New York Times, 9 December 2001, 15

NYT0102 - "Land O'Lakes ordered to pay inventor", New York Times, 3 January 2002, C2; inventor splits $3,000,000 award with lawyers, Patent Enforcement and Royalties of Toronto

NYT0102a - "Chip maker settles patent dispute", New York Times, 17 January 2002, C2

NYT0402 - "$8 million advance for 'Cold Mountain' author's next novel", New York Times, 7 April 2002, 22

NYT0402a - "Medtronic must pay rival $158 million", New York Times, 26 April 2002, C5

NYT0502 - "IBM chairman lines up a book deal for himself", New York Times, 1 May 2002, C8

NYT0502a - "An academic ready to take the plunge into novelistic success", New York Times, 27 May 2002, B1 (Yale professor gets $4.2 million advance for two books, one of which is to be written). See also "Is it a long good buy?", Newsweek, 1 July 2002, 58

NYT0602 - "Hollywood's Portfolio: Personal Marketing", New York Times Magazine, 9 June 2002, 108, (George Foreman sells the rights to his name to the makers of George Foreman Grills for $137.5 million)

NYT0602a - "Gillette ordered to pay $10 million to Syndia", New York Times, 19 June 2002, C4 (patent for coating razor blades with diamond-like carbon).

NYT0802 - "HARDWARE: Medical patent case decided", New York Times, 22 August 2002, C9 (patent for minimally invasive abdominal surgery).

NYT0802a - "Nine rescued coal miners sell TV and book rights to Disney", New York Times, 4 August 2002, 12 (the 9 miners received $150,000 each for their tales of being trapped three days in a mine)

NYT0902 - "Eli Lilly in deal for rights to a new drug for diabetes", New York Times, 21 September 2002, B1 - Amylin gets $80 million upfront, plus Lilly will spend $30 million to buy a 2 percent stake in Amylin. Amylin receives the remaining $215 million if it meets development and marketing goals.

NYT0902a - "Medtronic and Boston Scientific settle patent dispute", New York Times, 21 September 2002, B4

NYT1102 - "Honing the science of the release date", New York Times, 11 November 2002, C9 - discusses HarperCollins plans to release Michael Crichton's new book "Prey", the first book in a two book deal that cost HarperCollions $30 million for the English language rights

NYT1202 - "Broadcom buys patents from Unova", New York Times, 27 December 2002, C3; Broadcom buys 150 patents and patent applications for $24 million

NYT0103 - Interpore gets $15,000,000 plus future royalties after judge ruled against J&J unit DePuy AcroMed in a patent lawsuit. New York Times, 28 Jan 2003, C4

NYT0103a - A jury found that Safety1st infringed Mattel's patents on portable bassinets and baby bouncers. New York Times, 25 Jan 2003, B4

NYT0103c - "Disney sues Blockbuster over contract", New York Times, 10 Jan 2003, B2; before 1997, Blockbuster paid Disney $65/video. In a new agreement, subject to the lawsuit, Blockbuster paid only $7/video, plus a portion of the revenue. In the lawsuit, Disney seeks $120 million

NYT0103b - Supreme Court Justice will get advance for a book on his life story. New York Times, 10 Jan 2003, A19

NYT0203 - "With Michael Jackson, the gloves are off", New York Times, 17 February 2003, B1; Fox pays for authorized life story of Michael Jackson, purchased to counter similar deal between Granada and ABC

NYT0503 - "Iraqi who helped rescue Pfc. Lynch gets book deal", New York Times, 9 May 2003, A17; HarperCollins pays Mohammed Odeh al-Rehaief, a lawyer who helped the marine escape from an Iraqi hospital, $500,000 to write a book

NYT0509 - Medinol had accused Boston Scientific of breach of contract, fraud and theft of designs relating to stents. To settle, Boston Scientific paid $750 million and returned its 22% stake in Medinol. New York Times, 22 September 2005, C18.

NYT0504 - Medtronic will pay $550 to settle the lawsuit, and $800 million to acquire spinal surgery patents from Dr. Gary Michelson and his company, Karlin Technology. New York Times, 23 April 2005, B1.

NYT0505 - Jury convicts Alcon of infringing two Advanced Medical's cataract surgery patents. New York Times, 7 May 2005, B4. See also - The Recorder (SF), 16 May 2005, 4.

NYT0505 - A&E will pay at least $2.5 million for 65 episodes already broadcasted, as well as $2.5 million for new ten episodes. The $2.5 million is a record, beating the $1.9 million paid by Bravo to license "Law and Order: Criminal Intent". New York Times, 1 Feb 2005, B1

NYT0404 - Elan sells its Frova migraine drug to Vernalis for $55 million, and sells its Zonegran epilepsy drug to Eisai. New York Times, 1 April 2004, W1.

NYT0312 - Microsoft settles a patent infringement lawsuit with SPX Corp., over SPX's patent on real-time conferencing software. New York Times, 26 December 2003, C2.

NPN1297 - "Jury awards Unocal $68 million by six majors for patent violations", National Petroleum News, December 1997, 13

OREG0202 - "Nike loses Presto lawsuit in France", The Oregonian, 8 February 2002, B1

REC1000 - "Lawyer, firm settle trade secrets case for $12 millon", The Recorder, 18 September 2000, 2; see also WSJ10001

RDI0101 - Signet Book buys the paperback rights to Stephen King's Carrie for $400,000. Readers Digest, January 2001, 120.

REC1100 - "Jury award cut in Santa Clara case", The Recorder, 28 November 2000, 7; in January 2001, Caliper dismissed all claims against Aclara including $35,000,000 judgment as both companies dropped patent infringement lawsuits against each other - San Francisco Chronicle, 9 January 2001, page C7, "Aclara shares rise"

SCI0508 - patent is for word completion software. Science, 12 August 2005, 1011.

SDM0498 - "Wireless technology at issue in patent case", Security Distributing & Marketing, April 1998, 85; see also Markman. The judgment was reversed on appeal to the Federal Circuit. See the unpublished opinion 1999 U.S. App. Lexis 11166.

SFBJ0602 - "Cell Genesys transforms patents into gold mines", San Francisco Business Times, 14-20 June 2002, 16 (Cell Genesys licenses gene altering patents to Transkaryotic Therapies for $26 million ($11 million cash plus $15 million TT stock) in addition to milestone payments. But CG will not receive royalties from product sales)

SFC1199 - "Genentech deal in UC suit: $200 million offered to end DNA theft allegations", San Francisco Chronicle, 17 Nov 1999, A24; "Genentech settlement raises ante for rates", San Francisco Daily Journal, 22 Nov 1999, 1

SFC0500 - "Gene therapy institute scaled back after patient's death", San Francisco Chronicle, 25 May 2000, A7

SFC1200 - "3DFX Sells Off Assets", San Francisco Chronicle, 16 Dec 2000, D1; see also "Nvidia the last graphics survivor", Electronic News, 18 Dec 2000, 4

SFC0201 - "$18 million licensing deal boosts BioTime's stock", San Francisco Chronicle, 19 Feb 2001, B5; $8.5 million for marketing + $4 million initial license + upto $5.5 million if sales and patent goals are reached.

SFC0301 - "Fox loses copyright suit on Schwarzenegger Film", San Francisco Chronicle, 8 Mar 2001, D3; see also "And ... action! A $19M scene", National Law Journal, 19 March 2001, A14

SFC1101 - "Gilead selling 3 drugs for up to $200 million", San Francisco Chronicle, 27 November 2001, B3 (OSI paid $130 million cash and $40 million in stock for cancer drugs and patents)

SFC0102 - "Universal pays $4.75 million in royalty suit", San Francisco Chronicle, 18 January 2002, D9 (Vivendi to pay up to 300 musicians for underpaid royalties)

SFC0202 - "Esprit sells trademark rights to sister firm in Hong Kong", San Francisco Chronicle, 8 February 2002, B1

SFC0502 - "Macromedia, Adobe split patent lawsuits", San Francisco Chronicle, 11 May 2002, B2; (arbitration panel orders Adobe to pay Macromedia $4,900,000, and orders Macromedia to pay Adobe $2,820,000)

SFC0502a - "The In Crowd: Home Improvements", San Francisco Chronicle, 31 May 2002, D20, (Claudia Schiffer sold wedding photographs to Hello magazine)

SFC0602 - "Software pirate must pay, gets prison", San Francisco Chronicle, 18 June 2002, B2 (San Jose man, Inder Deot, convicted for illegally selling Microsoft software. Has to pay $10,000,000 in restitution and eight months in prison)

SFC0602a - "Genentech tries to stave off punishment damages", San Francisco Chronicle, 19 June 2002, B3 (Jury awards $300 million to City of Hope National Medical Center for lost royalties due from Genentech). "Genentech faces $500 million charge", Wall Street Journal, 25 June 2002, D4 ($200 million is added as punitive damages)

SFC0702 - "Publishers in bidding war for 'Dirty Girls'", San Francisco Chronicle, 2 July 2002, D6 (author gets nearly $500,000 in auction to five publishers for rights to her book)

SFC0802 - Jury rules Media Group made illegal copies of 1,500 songs since 1995, and had to pay damages of $90,000 per song. RIAA does not expect to collect, since Media Group (Fremont, CA) is bankrupt. San Francisco Chronicle, 24 Aug 2002, B2

SFC0902 - "Inventor's wife saw first glimpse of TV", San Francisco Chronicle, 7 September 2002, D1 (the inventor of television gets beat up by RCA Victor but gets $1,000,000 for his invention of the television)

SFC1002 - "Liquid Audio to sell patent rights to Microsoft", San Francisco Chronicle, 1 October 2002, B4 - LA sells Internet music security patents to Microsoft

SFC1102 - "Fremont woman sentenced for copying software", San Francisco Chronicle, 26 November 2002, B2 - Lisa Chan had illegally sold over 6,350 copies of Microsoft software

SFC0403 - The case involved Integraph patents on microprocessor designed infringed by Intel's Itanium chip. San Francisco Chronicle, 31 March 2004, C1.

SFC0409 - Nastech signs a deal with Merck over Nastech's nasal spray appetite suppressant PYY. Nastech gets $5 million upfront, and $341 million if certain goals are achieved, plus royalties on any future sales. Merck will take over testing and development, and Nastech will focus on manufacturing. San Francisco Chronicle, 28 September 2004, D5.

SFC0411 - The settlement ends a case before the U.S. International Trade Commission and a lawsuit in a federal district court. San Francisco Chronicle, 30 November 2004, C5. See also http://www.nwfusion.com/news/2004/1130sonytpoa.html

SFC0503 - The jury rules that Toshiba stole Lexar's trade secrets involving flash memory chips and cards. Toshiba pays $381 million in compensatory damages and $84 million in punitive damages. San Francisco Chronicle, 25 March 2005, C1.

SFC0508 - Miva settles with Yahoo over it's pay-per-click software patent. Yahoo had earlier settled with Google. San Francisco Chronicle, 15 August 2005, D9.

SFDJ0701 - "Avant ordered to pay $182M restitution", San Francisco Daily Journal, 20 July 2001, 1

SJMN0199 - "What goes around comes around", San Jose Mercury News, 20 January 1999, 3C

SJMN0100 - "San Jose start-up sold for $1 billion", San Jose Mercury News, 27 January 2000, 1C

SJMN0701 - "Xilinx and Altera settle patent battle", San Jose Mercury News, 19 July 2001, 1C

SJMN0202 - "Singer ordered to pay $71,000 for lifting lyrics", San Jose Mercury News, 15 February 2002, 2A

SJMN0103 - George Foreman has received at least $187 million for lending his name to the marketing of grilling machines San Jose Mercury news, 21 Jan 2003, 8C

SJMN0203 - To date, Hasbro has paid Lucas $470,000,000 for selling toys based on the movie "Star Wars". San Jose Mercury News, 1 Feb 2003, 8C

SM0997 - "Microsoft takes a bite", Software Magazine, September 1997, 27

TBT0492 - "Camera Makers Focus on Legal Problems, Possible Patent War", Tokyo Business Today, April 1992, 7; also "From the Mind of Minolta - Oops, Make that 'Honeywell'", Business Week, 24 February 1992, 34

TIM0303 - "Celine Dion got a new theater and millions of dollars to perform in Vagas", Time, 17 March 2003, 67; in exchange for five shows a week, 40 years a year, for three years, Celine Dion will get a reported $100,000,000 plus 50% of the profits. Caesars Palace with be charging anywhere from $90 to $200 a ticket, and is expecting a million people a year to see Dion perform.

TS0303 - "Ericsson settles patent lawsuit", Toronto Star, 18 March 2003; InterDigital shares rose as much as 41% the day the settlement is announced.

USPQ1617 US Patent Quarterly printed decisions, 16 USPQ2d 1481 and 17 USPQ2d 1711

VAR0502 "UPN's $4 mil brings 5 pix from Miramax", Daily Variety, 22 May 2002, 4 (UPN gets three Jackie Chan movies, the third sequel in "The Crow" franchise, and a 1998 supernatural thriller starring Ben Affleck)

VAR0802 "Tyros, composers and classics vie for ad time", Variety, 29 July 2002, A4 (article reports that Microsoft reportedly paid $10,000,000 for unlimited use of music from Madonna's 'Ray of Light' album)

WP0500 - "Jury finds in favor of VA firm in patent case", Washington Post, 06 May 2000, E02; also "Little fish fights big fish and may have a triple win", National Law Journal, 22 May 2000, B8; see also "Infringement charge gets through the pipeline", National Law Journal, 19 February 2001, C15 reporting that $55 million judgement increased to $68.75 million

WRD0901 - "The economics of adoption - music formats", WIRED, September 2001, 74

WSJ0299 - "P&G diaper dispute is settled for $163 million", Wall Street Journal, 2 February 1999, B14 (see also www.morganfinnegan.com/news/releases/diaper.html - original lawsuit damages were $178 million)

WSJ0899 - "Gateway to revive Amiga for info appliances", Wall Street Journal, 12 August 1999, B6; Gateway buys 47 Amiga computer patents for $13,000,000 from Escom, which had bought them from a bankrupt Commodore

WSJ1099 - "Glaxo Wellcome to trim 3,400 jobs and cut costs by 7%", Wall Street Journal, 6 October 1999, B2 (Glaxo settles lawsuit with the University of Minnesota, paying $7.25 million initially and an estimated $300,000,000 in royalties on a sliding fee scale, for the anti-AIDS drug Ziagen)

WSJ1299 - "Little known Ranbaxy makes a splash in look-alike drugs, seeks its own breakthroughs", Wall Street Journal, 28 December 1999, B1

WSJ0100 - "Bayer, Exelixis in $200 million research pact", Wall Street Journal, 11 January 2000, B4

WSJ0300 - "Wal-Mart is ordered to pay $50 million to P.O. Market", Wall Street Journal, 27 March 2000, A26; decision reversed, "TRADE SECRETS", National Law Journal, 25 February 2002, A15

WSJ10001 - "Caliper Technologies awarded $52.6 million in suit against Aclara", Wall Street Journal, 31 October 2000, B26; and "Caliper wins $52.6 million patent suit", San Francisco Chronicle, 31 October 2000, C1

WSJ1000 - "Appeal of $20 million award vowed in trade secrets suit", Wall Street Journal, 19 October 2000, B20

WSJ1100 - "Patent infringement suit by unit of GE is settled", Wall Street Journal, 13 November 2000, B19

WSJ1200 - "Qualcomm ordered to share royalties from CDMA sales", Wall Street Journal, 12 December 2000, B6

WSJ12001 - "Johnson & Johnson wins $324.4 million in patent suit against Boston Scientific", Wall Street Journal, 18 December 2000, B4; reversed in 2002 - "J&J dealt blow in stent case", Boston Globe, 7 April 2002, D2

WSJ12002 - "Medtronic is ordered to pay J&J damages in stent patent case", Wall Street Journal, 22 December 2000, A16; verdict reversed in 2002 - "Patent's history leans to reversal", National Law Journal, 22 April 2002, B8

WSJ01011 - "Cancer drug developer gets partners", Wall Street Journal, 9 January 2001, C6; OSI Pharmaceuticals to get up to $187 in payment and equity investments, plus profits from sales if the FDA approves the cancer drug - Genentech and Roche will pay $35 million each as part of the deal for a 1.5% stake in OSI.

WSJ01012 - "ThoughtWorks made illegal use of other's software", Wall Street Journal, 31 January 2001, B9

WSJ0301 - "Oh, Brother! Disney dips into honey pot for Pooh characters", Wall Street Journal, 5 March 2001, B7

WSJ0601 - "H-P will pay Pitney $400 million to settle printer technology suit", Wall Street Journal, 5 June 2001, A4

WSJ06011 - "Why new 'Tomb Raider' movie won't be a game", Wall Street Journal, 15 June 2001, B1; 'Tomb Raider' gamemaker Eidos PLC is getting $14 million plus 3% of the gross receipts of sales for the 2001 movie 'Lara Croft: Tomb Raider' from Viacom, who licensed the rights in 1998

WSJ0701 - "Jury says St. Jude Medical violated Guidant heart-defibrillator patent", Wall Street Journal, 5 July 2001, B2; however the judgment was reversed as reported in "$140 million patent award is reversed", National Law Journal, 25 February 2002, A10

WSJ07011 - "Panel orders damages paid in Boston Scientific case", Wall Street Journal, 19 July 2001, B2

WSJ0801 - "Companies revive has-beens instead of creating brands", Wall Street Journal, 21 August 2001, B2; bankrupt Bugle Boy Industries had its assets auctioned. Tropical Sportswear bid $52,000,000 just for the Bugle Boy trademark, with Schottenstein Stores paying $68.6 million for trademark and inventory.

WSJ0901 - "J&J must pay damages to Boston Scientific in stent-patent dispute", Wall Street Journal, 10 Sept 2001, B8

WSJ1201 - "Court awards $3 million to rap group", Wall Street Journal, 18 Dec. 2001, C9

WSJ0102 - "Roche unit ordered to pay Igen $505 million for patent violations", Wall Street Journal, 11 Jan. 2002, B6; $400 million was punitive damages, $105 million compsenatory. Igen also gained rights to a Roche diagnostic product line.

WSJ0402 - "Authors win $32.4 million judgment", Wall Street Journal, 25 April 2002, A11

WSJ0402a - "Intel to pay Intergraph $300 million in settlement", Wall Street Journal, 16 April 2002, A3 (Intel will also potentially pay an additional $250 million in a related patent lawsuit)

WSJ0402b - "Aventis to license cancer drug from Genta for up to $480 million", Wall Street Journal, 30 April 2002, D4 (Genta receives $135 million initially, $280 million cash and $65 million in convertible notes as milestone payments)

WSJ0502 - "Jupiter Media Metrix lawsuit over patent infringement ends", Wall Street Journal, 8 May 2002, B2 also "NetRatings settles with Jupiter Media Matrix", San Francisco Chronicle, 8 May 2002, B2 (NetRatings pays Jupiter $15 million, but acquires Jupiter's online tracking patents)

WSJ0502a - "Schering to buy cancer drug from Immunex for $380 million", Wall Street Journal, 6 May 2002, B6 (Schering will also pay two additional milestone payments based on regulatory approvals).

WSJ0502b - "InterTrust signs licensing deal", Wall Street Journal, 23 May 2002, B8 (Sony will license all of Intertrust's patents for $28.5 million plus future royalties)

WSJ0502c - "Judgment in patent case", Wall Street Journal, 25 May 2002, B3 (Judge orders Waters Corporation to pay Applera and MDS $52.6 million for infringing chemical analysis patents)

WSJ0502d - "Cognos Inc. agrees to pay $24 million to business objects", Wall Street Journal, 29 May 2002, B4 (Cognos will pay $10 million initially, and then quarterly payments of $1.75 million)

WSJ0502e - "Ireland buys a trove of Joyce notebooks", Wall Street Journal, 31 May 2002, B5 (Leon family of France sells collection of Jame Joyce's notebooks)

WSJ0702 - "Honeywell receives payment from patent settlement", Wall Street Journal, 30 July 2002, C4

WSJ1102 - "Ryder System - trademark infringement suit is settled with Budget Group", Wall Street Journal, 25 November 2002, B6

WSJ1102a - "Research in Motion - U.S. jury awards $23.1 million to NTP over patent dispute", Wall Street Journal, 22 November 2002, B6

WSJ1102b - "Cadence accepts $265 million to settle suit", Wall Street Journal, 14 November 2002, B3

WSJ1102c - "Sony, Philips to but InterTrust, gaining control of key patents", Wall Street Journal, 14 November 2002, B6 - Sony/Philips get control of InterTrust's 26 patents, 11 of which are being asserted against Microsoft

WSJ1102d - Judge rules Intel infringed some Intergraph microprocessor patents. If Intel appeals and loses, or licenses, Intergraph gets another $100,000,000 Wall Street Journal, 11 Oct 2002, B4

WSJ1102e - 3Com and Xircom settled multiple patent lawsuits against each other, with 3Com getting $15,000,000 and all of the patents cross-licensed. Wall Street Journal, 13 Nov 2002, D14

WSJ0103 - "Not necessarily the NFL", Wall Street Journal, 10 Jan 2003, W4; advertisers say the NFL charges $2000 to $3000 per second for football game film clips

WSJ0203 - "In a style replay, it's Ralph's turn to fight with a licensee", Wall Street Journal, 5 Feb 2003, B1; Jones Apparel in 2002 paid Polo $65 million, mostly as royalties for Polo's Lauren line of clothing.

WSJ0303 - "Deal offers Novartis a foothold in viral drugs" - Wall Street Journal, 27 Mar 2003, C8; Novartis will buy 51% of Idenix Pharmaceuticals for $225 million, plus pay $75 million to license the rights to two hepatitis B drugs. If milestones are met, Novartis will pay hundreds of millions of dollars more.

WSJ0403 - "Royalty rate is set for Web use", Wall Street Journal, 4 Apr 2003, B5; webcasters will pay music rights groups royalties in 2003 and 2004 for broadcasting music over the Internet as follows: 11% of gross revenues, or 0.0762 cents per song per listener or 0.0117 cents per listener hour.

WSJ0503 - "Global Business Briefs: Novell Inc", Wall Street Journal, 20 May 2003, C10; Computer Commodity penalized for selling stolen Novell software

WSJ0511 - Microsoft will pay RealNetworks $460 million in cash and $300 million in promotions on Microsoft's Internet Web sites to help promote RealNetworks' online music and games services. Wall Street Journal, 12 October 2005, B5.

WSJ0505 - HP will buy $325 million of EMC's products for internal use or resale over a five year period. The two companies signed a five-year cross licensing agreement. Wall Street Journal, 5 May 2005, B3.

WSJ0503 - CKX, also known as Sports Entertainment Enterprises, buys 19 Entertainment, which created and owns the "American Idol"/"Pop Idol" reality television franchises. The $174 million buyout comprises $124 million in cash, and the 1,870,558 shares of CKX. Wall Street Journal, 21 March 2005, B3.

WSJ05031 - Otamedia was convicted of selling Philip Morris' branded cigarettes in the United States from their Web site. Wall Street Journal, 15 March 2005, B6

WSJ0409 - Applied Materials also waived $3.5 million in disputed patent royalties. Wall Street Journal, 27 September 2004, A12.

WSJ04091 - Settlement involves a Chiron HIV-testing patent. Chiron also gets to keep monies paid by Roche during the lawsuit. The $78 million is a lump sum payment for all royalties beyond January 2005. Wall Street Journal, 13 September 2004, B10.

WSJ0308 - Hilgraeve had sued in 1997 over anti-virus software patents. Symantec will also buy some of Hilgraeve's patents. Wall Street Journal, 19 August 2003, B6.

WSJ0305 - Le Bron James signs seven year deal with Nike, getting a $10,000,000 signing bonus. Nike will market a line of basketball shoes in James' name. Wall Street Journal, 23 May 2003, B5.